ABA Photo Quiz

ABA Online Bird Photo Quiz 12


Bird Photo

Identifying many birds in flight can be challenging. Birds often fly away from us. They're often far away. And, they can be at difficult angles. But soaring raptors are when raptors are at their easiest. They'll circle lazily overhead and you can typically see all of their underparts and get a great perspective at shape.

The first step is to place our bird in the right group of raptors. Falcons and most kites have wings that appear longer, more pointed and not as broad. Hook-billed and Snail Kites have much broader wings. Any accipiter would have a much longer tail and the underparts of the body would be either barred (adults and 2nd cycle birds) or heavily streaked (juveniles). Eagles don't match our bird on plumage or shape.

We are left with the Buteos and closely related genera. Still there are some birds that we can quickly eliminate. Harris's Hawk is distinctive in all ages. Zone-tailed Hawk is completely different. Even juvenile Common Black-Hawks have broader wings and more extensive markings on the underparts (adults have all dark bodies). Juvenile Gray Hawks are rather similar to our bird, but the trailing edge of the wings would be pale, the cheeks would be much paler and contrast markedly with the dark malar, and the dark tail bands would be more pronounced.

At this point, we should look more carefully at the shape. For a Buteo the wings are rather pointed. Some of this may be caused by the outer primaries being held closed, but even accounting for that the wings seem more pointed than we would expect on Red-tailed, Rough-legged and Ferruginous Hawks. The darker primaries and secondaries that contrast markedly with the pale underwing coverts also eliminate Red-tailed, Rough-legged and Ferruginous Hawk

The pointed wings may suggest Swainson's Hawk, but that species has longer and narrower wings. Adults Swainson's would also have a complete bib, and even the palest juveniles would show more dark markings on the sides of the upper breast.

Red-shouldered Hawk isn't right for our bird either-the underparts are not as heavily marked, and, with this type of backlit view, we would see obvious crescent-shaped pale wing panels on a Red-shouldered Hawk.

Broad-winged Hawks look rather similar to our bird. Some juvenile Broad-winged Hawks are very pale below, almost matching out bird. The underwing coverts of Broad-winged Hawks typically show at a few more markings than on our bird. On a Broad-winged Hawk that is this pale, the secondaries should be paler and show a more distinct dark trailing edge.

This leaves us with Short-tailed Hawk. The dark primaries and secondaries that contrast with a white area at the base of the inner primaries are typical of Short-tailed Hawks. The dark brown head that contrasts with a white throat (and only subtly paler cheek) is also expected on juvenile light-morph Short-tailed Hawks. I photographed this rather classic juvenile light-morph Short-tailed Hawk outside of the Manzanillo airport in Jalisco, Mexico.


The following people (listed by submission date beginning with the earliest) submitted correct answers for the March Bird Photo Quiz—Short-tailed Hawks:

  1. Nicholas Pederson, Albuquerque, NM
  2. Aaron Boone, Columbus, OH
  3. Tim White, Bluffton, SC
  4. Manuel Mondejar, Taos, NM
  5. Alison Village, Berrien Springs, MI
  6. Chris Benesh, Tucson, AZ
  7. Matt Pike, Lacey, WA
  8. Bill Maynard, Monument, CO
  9. Larry Semo, Westminster, CO
  10. James P. Smith, Keene, NH
  11. Dennis Arendt, Eugene, OR
  12. Raymond VanBuskirk, Albuquerque, NM
  13. Tom Smith, Waltham, MA
  14. Sandra Lautrup, Effingham, IL
  15. Wes Serafin, Orland Park, IL
  16. Dave Weber, Milpitas, CA
  17. Susannah Lerman, Keene, NH
  18. Steven Gedeon, Oradell, NJ
  19. Chris Jacobs, Dillsburg, PA
  20. Travis A. Mahan, Decatur, IL
  21. Robert Doster, Albuquerque, NM
  22. Diane Powell, Kathleen, GA
  23. George E. Wallace, Warrenton, VA
  24. Bill Schmoker, Longmont, CO
  25. Joe Bens, Cincinnati, OH
  26. Sean Prockter, South Salem, NY

How Did You Compare?

The graph below shows that the highest number of answers submitted was for Broad-winged Hawk (39), followed by Short-tailed Hawk (26). We received a number of answers that did not conform to the ABA Checklist format. Please note that answers must consist simply of the Common or English name exactly as it appears in the ABA Checklist.

Bird Graph


The photo and answer for this quiz were supplied by Chris Wood.